Conferencing Solutions for Desktop Training

Can't get attorneys to come to training? Then take the training to them.

By Cindy L. Chick

Orignally Published April 2, 2001

Products Discussed
WEBEX Netmeeting

So you just recently subscribed to ANOTHER web product. It's Friday afternoon, and one of the tax attorneys in an office 3,000 miles away needs to use it for a research project. He/she couldn't find the time to attend the training session that was offered 3 weeks ago. The publisher's customer support/training staff have long since gone home. Now what?

The following week you are excited to find you actually have 5 attorneys who are willing to attend a training session on the same web product. The only problem is, they're all in different geographical locations. The vendor doesn't have training reps in each of those cities. What do you do?

The ability to offer a wide variety of training options, some on a "just-in-time" basis is becoming increasingly important. These days the typical law library offers a wide variety of Internet, CD and other online products. But the more products offered, the more difficult it becomes to get attorneys and other end users to attend quickly multiplying training sessions. Add to the mix the fact that many firms are increasingly become more "global", with legal staff in a variety of locations, some domestic, and some not, and it's obvious that even the old stand-by of free food may not be enough to solve the problem.

The vendors can help, but for the most part, they can't do it all. Librarians need to make the content that the firm is paying big bucks for accessible and useful, and so have to step in and find innovative ways to provide training where and when the users need it.

There's a number of ways to do this with new technologies. But one relatively quick and easy method is to use some of the new conferencing and collaboration software and services to deliver live training directly to the desktop. These services allow a trainer in any location to connect over the internal network, or over the web and conduct a training session from their own computer. They can be used conjunction with a traditional conference call, or these services can be used to transmit audio as well. Everything that the trainer does on their workstation is transmitted to the attendee(s). And they never have to leave their office.

There are many products out there to choose from, most of them on the web. In this article, I've included basic information on Netmeeting, WEBEX and Placeware, as well as some limited information on conference servers.

Netmeeting is NOT a web product, but it IS free. It requires a small program, downloadable from the Microsoft site, and is included with Windows98 and 2000. While it's fairly bare bones, it can easily be used within your network, therefore avoiding problems with potentially slow Internet connections. Just keep in mind that unlike the web products discussed, there is a limit of 8 attendees at a "netmeeting." (A conference server is necessary to accomodate more than 8.) If you have a video camera on your computer, you can even transmit video to attendees, though from what I hear, this is a feature that is best avoided. Netmeeting's capabilities can be extended by third party products, such as CUSEEME. (http://www.cuseeme.com/)

WEBEX and Placeware are both web products. Both offer free versions that you can use for a limited number of attendees with some functional limitations. The free versions can be great for getting your feet wet, and in some cases, for example, when you just need to do quick 10 minute one on one training session with an attorney in another office, might be all you need.

Both WEBEX and Placeware allow you to do several things such as share a whiteboard, present a Powerpoint presentation, and share applications. For training purposes the ability to share applications is likely the most important feature for training purposes, as it allows you to show a web session or demo any program that resides on your computer. It requires little on the part of the attendees, and nothing on the part of your Technical Services staff. But if your Internet connection is quirky and sometimes slow, beware. Successful use of web products require a consistently reliable connection.

More help is in sight. If we're looking at using these products, you can bet that the vendors that sell us all these research products are looking at them as well. Or at least, they should be.

Now if we can just find a way to transmit food electronically, we'd really have it made.

Conferencing Options

| Netmeeting | WEBEX | Placeware | Conference Servers |

Netmeeting from Microsoft

Web Page: Microsoft Netmeeting Page - http://www.microsoft.com/windows/netmeeting/

Price: Free, comes with Window98 & 2000, free download for Windows95.

Installation: Can download most recent version from Microsoft Netmeeting Page. Easy to install.

Features:

  • Offers application sharing, whiteboard, and text chats
  • Can broadcast video
  • Includes voice conferencing options

Caveats

  • Video performance reported to be poor
  • Windows only - no cross-platform sharing
  • Requires opening ports in the firewall if you want to meet outside your LAN/WAN
  • Not suitable for large audiences (over 20)
  • Not browser based.

For More Information:

Meeting by Wire
NetZone
NetMeeting 3.01 Rocks Data Sharing
Overview - Microsoft Netmeeting 3.0

 

WEBEX

Web Site: http://www.webex.com

Price

  • Free Meeting Center
  • Limited to a maximum of 4 users, you're also limited to using certain features , such as application sharing, for only 10 minutes.
  • Customized Conference Center
  • You can pay a monthly fee to get a customized conference center for your firm, or use WEBEX on a pay-per-use basis at a cost of $.35 per minute per user, charged to a credit card.
  • No limitations on the number of attendees.

Installation: Presenter must install browser plug-in. Participants can use java download, or install browser plug-in.

Features

  • Integrates with Outlook for sending email invitations
  • Offers application sharing
  • Can pass control from one participant to another
  • Desktop sharing with remote control possible by attendees and host
  • Can record and save the complete meeting
  • Web co-browsing
  • Support for live video
  • Works through firewall

Caveats

  • May experience degradation of image quality when using screenshots in Powerpoint presentations

For More Information:

Meet Online Next Time (PC World)
WEBEX.com/WEBEX Meeting Center (ZDNet)

 

Placeware

Web Site: http://www.placeware.com or http://www.myplaceware.com

Update: (Myplaceware.com to be suspended on May 1st, 2001)

Price

  • Offers free MyPlaceware.com for up to 4 participants.
  • MyPlaceware Pro offers additional features for $100 per month for 5 participants, and $200 per month for 10 participants.
  • Conference Center 2000 - $600 per seat per year, $3,000 set-up fee for customization of conference center.
  • Comparison of different services offered by Placeware available at http://www.placeware.com/services/index.html.
  • Complete Pricing Information - http://www.placeware.com/services/pricing.html

Installation

  • Requires installation of browser plugin for host.
  • Participants require no download of plugin. Anticipate some lead-time however due to download of java applets which can take 1-3 minutes.

Features

  • Livedemo features allows you to show any application on your workstation.
  • Web co-browsing, presenter's URL pushed to meeting participants.
  • Meetings can be recorded and archived
  • Integrates with Outlook for sending email invitations
  • Supports Powerpoint slides, even screenshots of good quality. Presentations must be uploaded in advance.
  • Works through firewall


Caveats

  • When web co-browsing, participants can click away from the meeting by clicking on links, etc.
  • No support for video
  • When using application sharing via Livedemo, cannot pass control to participants.


For More Information

MyPlaceWare/PlaceWare 3.5 Conference Center (ZDNet)
Global Meetings Made Easier (Infoworld)

 

 

Additional Information on Conference Servers

To conduct large meetings, a Conference Server is necessary. Among the options are:

Microsoft Exchange 2000 Conference Server

NetMeeting users connected to Exchange 2000 Conferencing Server have access to conferences and full integration of real-time meetings with their Microsoft Outlook® calendars.

Exchange 2000 Conferencing Server can be deployed in conjunction with Exchange 2000 Server or Exchange 2000 Enterprise Server, or can be installed and deployed separately as long as there is at least one Exchange 2000 Server and one Windows 2000 Server in the domain.

Web Page: http://www.microsoft.com/exchange/productinfo/conferencing.htm

Price: $3,999 (without Client Access License) http://www.microsoft.com/exchange/productinfo/pricing.htm

Annual Cost: Per Microsoft White Paper for Medium Company, 1,000 employees, 500 meetings per year - $108,875.

CUSEEME Conference Server

Web Page: http://www.cuseeme.com/software/conferenceserver.htm

Price: 25 Concurrent Users - Under $15,000)

Can use with any H.323 client including CUSEEME PRO, and Netmeeting.

CUSEEME Conferencing for Microsoft Exchange

Web Page: http://www.cuseeme.com/software/conferencingoption.htm

Integrates with Outlook, but requires Exchange 2000.

Placeware Meeting Center - Self-hosted

Web page - http://www.placeware.com - doesn't include information on the self-hosted option.

Price: $11,500 for 20 seats including $3,000 set-up fee and $8,500 annual licensing fee.

There is not upgrade path for this product, as Placeware is trying to develop the web product, not the self-hosted model.